Green and Gold: Studies in Landscape
and Urban Regeneration in Derry, Northern Ireland
GSD 1402, Landscape Architecture Studio
GSD 1505, Urban Planning & Design Studio
with Virginie Lefebvre, Fall 2005
SPONSORS
- Derry City Council
- ILEX Regeneration Company
- North West Office, Department for Social Development
- McGinnis Group, Property Developers
PEDAGOGICAL GOALS
The quality of a city’s open spaces has the power to transform
the lives of those who inhabit them. We believe that our spirits
are enlivened by what our senses perceive, and that the physical
design of the public realm can alter the perceptions of the city
to both its citizens and to the world.
The site that we focus on, the Ebrington Barracks in Derry, Ireland,
is very much in the public eye and consciousness, however it carries
with it a negative legacy. It has been recently decommissioned
from an active base where the Unionist army waged war against
the IRA. With its decommissioning, we have been asked to devise
a program for the site that serves the citizens of Derry in very
pragmatics ways, whether that is to propose housing, cultural
facilities, civic facilities—whatever comes out of our studio’s
exploration at the beginning of the studio, and to determine the
physical nature of the open spaces that come out of the program.
It is our responsibility as designers to bring more to such a
situation than program, by imbuing the buildings and open spaces
with meaning through physical design. The Studio focuses not on
the specifics of the architecture but more heavily on the design
of the public open spaces. The design of these spaces must serve
to create a sense of place, identity and pride. These are program
requirements which ultimately create space that is highly valued
and therefore sustained.
The overall goal for the studio is to deliver a project that:
- celebrates a new era of peace for the people of Derry
- expresses the knitting together of a city that has been divided
(this is reinforced by a new bridge that is being considered
at this site that provides a much needed link between the east
and west sides of the river).
- creates a symbol for the rest of Europe that Derry is up and
running and open for business
- and new hopefulness and that Derry is a good place to live,
work and raise a family
- symbolizes the NEW Derry- a city that is at peace and ready
to move forward after having been frozen in conflict for 25
years.
The studio’s goal is to provide realistic ideas and innovative
concepts that are well illustrated in the form of models and drawings
so as to excite, motivate and give the citizens of Derry a palpable
vision for the Ebrington Barracks that take them forward with
the site’s development.
EBRINGTON BARRACKS HISTORY
Ebrington Barracks is a very recently decommissioned army barracks.
This is no benign army facility that has no live memory and is
simply fading out through disuse. It has been in use during war-time
conditions until recently and has many negative connotations for
the citizens of Derry.
This is a roughly 24 acre site, on the west (or Protestant side)
of the Foyle River, opposite from the city center which occupies
the east bank (or the Catholic side ) of the Foyle
The site contains a walled, star-shaped fortress and numerous
buildings that have been built in different eras and for different
conflicts. The last army to use the fort was fighting the IRA
during the “trouble” – the 30 year struggle
between the Republicans ( IRA forces) and Loyalists forces which
began in 1960? on “Bloody Sunday”. The fort has been
used by the Protestant or UK forces as a base to fight against
the IRA .
A number of buildings on the site are listed- these being the
oldest. They are to be re-commissioned and new uses are to be
determined for them. However, more than half of them can be taken
down. The new uses for this site are not yet determined; however
this is a site that is of historical importance in the long and
stormy history of Derry and one that has a strong presence in
the city of Derry, as it sits high upon a ridge and is visually
prominent.
Additionally, a new bridge has been proposed at the south end
of the site at Waterside Roundabout that would connect the two
banks of Derry, which at the present are difficult to access due
to the long distance between the two existing bridges. The lack
of connection between the two banks has been a necessity for peace-keeping
between the two districts in this highly divided city. Now that
peace is possible and likely, there is a need to pull the city
together both metaphysically as well as physically. This bridge,
the attendant public spaces where they meet the land, along with
the planning, programming and designing of the barracks site is
the studio problem.
PROBLEM
We endeavor to both devise a program or use for the site that
serves the citizens of Derry in very pragmatics ways, whether
that is to propose housing, cultural facilities, civic facilities—whatever
comes out of a brief but focuses exploration at the beginning
of the studio and to determine the physical nature of the open
spaces that come out of the program. It is our responsibility
as designers to bring more to such a situation by imbuing the
buildings and open spaces with meaning through design. The Studio
focuses not on the buildings but all the open spaces around the
buildings. The design of these landscapes must serve to create
a sense of place, identity and pride. These are included in our
list of program requirements and which ultimately create space
that is highly valued and therefore sustained
The students are asked to determine, in general terms, what the
use and purpose of the Ebrington site ought to be. We are being
asked to re-establish a new purpose for the site and re-invigorate
the public life and image of Derry. This is both a practical and
an ethical exercise, since we determine, to a large degree, what
sort of activities are encouraged and discouraged in this district.
Given there is a stock of registered buildings of historic importance,
the class is asked to evaluate these buildings for future re-use
and to determine what other buildings might be used or taken away
for future building sites.
Additionally, there has been a proposal for a new bridge and
station at the northern end of the site. The students will be
asked to evaluate the necessity of these infrastructural elements,
and if they are seen as positive elements, how they integrate
into the existing points of contact on the banks of the river.
The project brief considers the following:
- Providing an assessment of the proposed mix of uses for the
site in the Planning Service Document)
- Assessment of available research regarding the potential for
future use of the sites based on market demand.
- The planning and design of the proposed uses for the site
to illustrate the potential for the regeneration of the city
and region
- The development of a program to include a mix of uses for
the site including the public realm, open space, landscaping,
place making and integration with the existing fabric of the
city.
- The use of innovative ideas and approaches and creative design
solutions in the reuse of the site
- The use of examples of good practice and precedents from
Europe and North America to substantiate the proposals for the
Derry sites.
- Recommendations for the future development of the site based
on highest and best use.
COURSE STRUCTURE
The studio has a three-phase structure:
- First we gather data in Derry and the Ebrington Barracks site
during a one-week funded field trip to Derry and use this information
to inform our progress.
- Second, we conceptualize a Master Plan for the site based
on our observations, conversations with local stakeholders and
our own core values. We take into consideration the listed buildings
and ideas for program, as well as incorporate program based
upon conclusion from our initial planning study.
- Finally, we design a portion of the site ( TBD) in sufficient
detail to be able to understand the sensory implications of
the decisions that were made in the Master Planning phase.
Running in tandem to this exercise, the discussion of art and
it’s relationship to landscape design is a central topic
throughout the studio and design process.
The Regeneration of Harlow
GSD 1406, Spring 2005
With Jon Fitch guest Studio Critic
Generously Funded by CABE: Commission for Architecture and the
Built Environment, UK
COURSE DESCRIPTION
INTRODUCTION
The Schwartz Spring 2005 Option Studio focuses on the regeneration
of Harlow, a New Town, built in the late 1940's in the UK. Presently
there are issues around such New Towns in terms of how they have
aged over the last 70 years, as they have changed and adapted
to new circumstances, pressures and social evolution.
New Towns, such as Harlow, Letchworth Garden City and Milton
Keynes, had significant impact upon city building in the United
States, demonstrated in projects such as Reston, Virginia and
Columbia, Maryland. Many of the PUD's built in the 60's in the
US were based upon the philosophy and structures of these early
New Towns first conceived of and built in the UK.
Presently, new realities and pressures have impacted these aging
New Towns negatively, causing the government of the UK to re-visit
such New Towns to try to improve their conditions. These conditions
include the fact that the populations who live there are stagnant
– the people who live and grow up there rarely move on or
climb up the socio-economic ladder. Consequently, the populations
have aged and have tended to be monolithic. The increasing age
of the population has created a lack of incentive, money and action
to keep the community vital. People are on limited pensions with
little economic resources. These factors, in turn, negatively
impact the quality of the public facilities, such as the vast
amounts of green open space, which characterize so profoundly
these New Towns.
This studio examines the affects of aging upon Harlow, a New
Town whose initial image and offer rested so heavily upon the
inclusion of a bold and expansive open space. Our assignment will
be to assess the function and value of this open space that is
so cherished by the residents of Harlow, and how to solve the
need for growth so that it remains in balance with the value of
the open space. While doubling the size of the New Town, we must
still try to retain the original spirit and sense of place created
for Harlow by the original designer, Sir Frederick Gibberd.
HISTORY
Harlow was planned as a first generation New Town in the late
1940’s. It was designed by Sir Frederick Gibberd to accommodate
80,000 residents and significant industry as an overspill center
outside Greater London. The original masterplan was formed around
a series of local neighborhood centers interconnected by a generous
provision of green space.
Harlow now has an aging urban fabric as has suffered from significant
underinvestment in recent years. As part of the national Sustainable
Communities Plan, Harlow has been identified by the government
as a key centre for growth and could potentially double in size
within the next two decades. Improving the quality of green space
is seen as a key component of this emerging agenda.
While the network of green spaces was originally conceived as
an integral part of the original masterplan, their quality and
value has been reduced in recent years. What was once a key asset
to the town has increasingly become a liability through loss of
purpose, changing culture, poor design quality, impact of traffic
and ever rising maintenance costs.
FUTURE
Harlow is presently in a growth area located between London and
Cambridge. It has been identified by the government as a key center
for growth and could double in size in the next two decades.
In order to both upgrade and re-establish itself as a desirable
place to live, visit and invest, it must reappraise the value
and purpose of its green fabric to ensure that it can accommodate
the needs and aspirations of a growing and changing population.
Transforming the quality in design of its green spaces should
be seen as an essential component within a comprehensive package
of urban regeneration and sustainable development initiatives.
The focus for this studio is therefore multi-fold:
- To appraise the original open space design intent of the Gibberd’s
masterplan.
- To identify the strengths, opportunities and weaknesses of
the town’s current network of public open spaces.
- To establish a series of design principles to improve the
quality, value and viability of Harlow’s green spaces
in response to changing demographic and cultural trends.
- To develop design proposals for one selected site that draws
on the design principles identified for above.(Ideally all students
should focus their work on the Town Park, particularly as it
may be easier to pull together necessary base information. Within
the entire park there is plenty of scope to focus on individual
areas)
- To use this as a vehicle to raise the debate about design
quality and purpose of green space within Growth Areas in general
and ageing New Towns in particular in the UK.
OUTCOME
This effort may help to improve the quality of life for Harlow’s
residents, as it is a live issue at present. The site has received
some central government funding that will go part way towards
its improvement. Local partners will be up to speed with issues
and by the spring will be starting to explore design options.
The Harvard Studio makes a valuable contribution to this process.
At the end of the studio, key conclusions are discussed in a
conference funded by CABE, after which the proceedings and conclusions
are put into a summary document produced by CABE Space.
11 Cities
and the Milan Convention Center Site
GSD 1402, Fall 2003
The profession of landscape architecture has had a relatively
small presence in Italy. The disciplines of architecture and urban
design have been well explored and taught through numerous schools,
producing more graduates than what has been able to be absorbed
in the profession.
Landscape architecture, however, has not had much representation
or visibility within the culture. It is, in part, a greater objective
of this studio to create a window into the profession of landscape
architecture so that the skills, which we have to offer as a profession,
might be illustrated to Italian government officials, students,
teachers and other design professionals.
The first step in this process is to identify a need, which the
profession can address, and then illustrate the process and the
results of how we, as a profession, might go about satisfying
this need. In other words, we must define an issue and then satisfy
it in order to make our case.
I have identified Milan as a city whose open-space is under siege
and in need of direction as to how to address their issues of
open-space. More specifically, Milan is a prospering city where
its need for growth and an expanding infrastructure is not easily
fitting within the constraints of its medieval infrastructure.
Parking lots are occupying precious open spaces, other valuable
open spaces are often falling into ruin, the canal system within
the city remain underdeveloped and undervalued as possible open-space
and whatever parks still exist have fallen under the pressure
of sprawling, un-dense development at its fringes.
One of the greatest challenges is to re-invest the landscape
with value, as the “fringe” landscape is both the
greatest and most neglected component of “sprawl”.
Given the low status of the landscape (in relation to architecture)
and its degraded image, it is, in fact, only through the design
of the landscape that meaningful connections between cities can
be made. Through the design of the landscape, an image can be
created and ecological reparations can be made to an environment
that is both ecologically and culturally squandered. It is through
the design of the landscape that cohesion, image, legibility and
identity can be achieved in this marginalized, “in-between”
type of landscape.
The topic of this studio is about the landscape of the urban
fringe. The students are given the task of creating identity,
order and legibility out of the landscape chaos of Milan’s
urban edge. In general, this is a very topical issue and can apply
to almost anywhere on the globe where city expansion is resulting
in the loose, formless spread of sub-urban development best known
as “sprawl”.
Although the problem is specific to this particular site and
problem, students experience dealing with a problem that one can
find down the street from one’s home, or in almost any country
one travels. The first step is to define the site, and then to
create a context, make a new image for the site and devise a strategy
in order to weave the new Convention Center back into existing
urban structures such as public transportation, road systems and
back to the city centers themselves.
Miasteczko
Wilanow; Landscape Matrix
GSD 1405, Spring 2003
Studio:
The studio focuses on the design of the public landscape and design
solutions for key elements of public space infrastructure for
Miasteczko Wilanow in Warsaw. Each student develops a strategic
approach to the design of a landscape infrastructure that embraces
the role of public space, strategies for ecological issues, transport
and circulation, recreation and leisure. As part of this a specific
strategy for the deployment of art in public space is developed
as a key component in the urban regeneration.
There are two major studies: The first is the investigation of
a design strategy for the intersection of the palace and its historic
landscape with the new urban district through the design of the
key public space linking the two. The second is design proposals
for a series of corridors within the development including a freeway,
a major boulevard, two canals and the associated open space.
Site:
Miasteczko Wilanow is described as a sustainable, mixed-use community
being built on a 169-hectare site across from the Wilanow Royal
Palace. The palace, originally built as an Italianate Villa Nova
beginning in 1679 and continuing into the next century, is now
a Royal Museum set within its own grounds which include gardens
from the 17th and 18th centuries. The palace and gardens were
comprehensively conserved and restored during the 1960s.
Historically, the area surrounding the palace was composed of
a series of small agricultural villages, woods, orchards, and
farmland. Since the Second World War they have been overtaken
by city growth and are part of Warsaw’s suburban expansion.
The current redevelopment strategy is an attempt to shape this
growth in such a way that it respects the 17th- and 18th-century
context, preserving traditional reservoirs, natural features and
key axes and geometry.
The new district includes a town hall and civic precinct, a lively
social, cultural, and retail center, residential neighborhoods,
a major church and associated schools and educational institutions,
and a major business park. The project is currently in the early
stages of construction.
Structure:
The studio visits Warsaw at the beginning of the semester for
approximately a week. Students work individually through the semester
to develop specific site design proposals. Following the final
review, the studio produces a publication of the proposals. The
studio is jointly taught by Martha Schwartz and Elizabeth Mossop.
Sponsored by PROKOM Investments and coordinated by Guy Perry INVI.
Milan’s
South Park
GSD 1403, Fall 2001
The purpose of this studio is to work with each student to explore
his or her own aesthetic in the conceptualization and design of
Milan's South Park. Students work from a larger urban design scale
during which larger open-space conditions of Milan are taken into
account, and through the semester work down to a site-scale where
specific design solutions are developed.
Introduction
Milan is the expanding industrial engine of Italy. As a result,
Milan's success is having a major and devastating impact upon
the open spaces and parks of its historic central core. By far,
the most visually disconcerting and environmentally damaging aspect
of these open spaces is the drastic placement of the automobile.
Indeed, virtually every possible open space has been negatively
impacted by cars. Everywhere you look in the still architecturally
exciting and important historic center, there are cars on top
of cars, quadruply parked. A statistic reports that there are
over 160,000 illegally parked cars in Milan every day, while no
tickets are issued.
Milan is in desperate need of an attitude adjustment in terms
of the use of the car. In a city world-renowned for its fashion
industry the visual degradation of the city is paradoxical. The
studio focuses first on developing proposals for how to create
an open-space system within the old city which is created through
the removal of cars, and which links to a major new open space
which form a major infra-structure for Milan's new development
to the south, South Park.
South Park
The major portion of the studio is spent on the development of
an intervention on a substantial area of land, about the size
of Central Park, included within an area called "Parco Sud
Milan" or South Park. This is a large protected agricultural
land that forms a green belt around the whole southern fringe
of the city.
This site has the unique characteristic of being in the process
of being enclosed from all sides by the urbanization and spreading
of the many municipalities of Milano. Most of these municipalities
are residential communities featuring relatively low-density developments
(4 - 5 story average height) that date back to the 60's and 70's.
These residential environments are desperately lacking open spaces
and venues for public life.
Schedule
The class starts off with a sketch problem, Design In A Box,
where we explore the relationship between art and landscape architecture.
We take a field trip to New York where we visit museums and galleries,
as well as spend a day looking at Central Park so to establish
a mental picture of the scale of the park, which is similar to
South Park.
The next portion of the class begins with a funded field trip
to Milan where students spend time looking at Milan's older center
and its open spaces. We then turn our attention to the South Park
site where we spend two days exploring, walking, and recording
information. During this time we meet with Dr. Carlo Ezechieli
from the Politecnico de Milano, Dipartimento de Architettura e
Pianificazione, who participates with us and is running a parallel
studio in Milan.
After the trip, students work individually to develop their own
strategy and design for South Park and how it might connect back
to the center through an open-space connection. These designs
are fully developed in plan, section, and model which are presented
to Milan city officials. An official jury awards a financial prize
to the best project, as well as second and third prizes. An exhibition
of all the projects is organized in January.
Master
Plan & Environmental Design Proposed for Cooper Union New York,
NY
GSD 1310-03, Fall 2000
Sakae Sugiura
MLA/MUP '01, Plan |
Cooper Union can hardly describe its environment
as a "campus." It exists now as a series of islands
in a confluence of rivers of cars. The area is roughly 6 city
blocks. The buildings which compose Cooper Union sit across major
avenues, parking lots, and undeclared open spaces creating a very
disjointed impression. There exists very little "there"
there, which may, ironically add to its present charm.
Cooper Union Square, if planned and designed well, could constitute
one of the major open spaces in Manhattan. Given the location
and the prestige of the school, the possibilities for its development
are great. In addition to all its complexities, it sits on top
of a great nexus of underground utilities and subways.
The site's northern boundary is at 9th Street. The blocks, all
somewhat triangular in shape, are bordered by 9th Street at the
North end, 6th Street at the Southern end, 2nd Avenue on the East
Side and Lafayette Street on the West Side. Within this complex
of buildings, streets and open spaces exists Astor Place which
is the site of sculptor Tony Rosenthal's "cube," an
important urban landmark in New York. Cooper Square is the other
important open space which composes this area.
While the school's administration has expressed the desire to
communicate its focus on technology and communication, within
a "hi tech" environment. The three schools - Art, Engineering,
Architecture - have somewhat separate agendas. The architecture
school, in particular, is very rooted in teaching the "spiritual
in architecture." John Hejduk, who had been dean for the
past 30 years, developed a program and faculty that perceive technology
at the service of the mind. Figure drawing and free-hand are still
at the basis of the Cooper curriculum. Christopher's seminar "Sound
As A Visual Medium" is, among other concepts, an investigation
into "formless materials"- sound and light, in conjunction
with models and drawings to investigate this realm of the "spirit"
within architecture.
Cooper Union is now in the process of trying to define a "campus"
for itself. There have been a number of proposals made over the
past 35 years, however there is a marked similarity found in the
street planning component of each proposal. Also, immediately
adjacent to Cooper Union is Ian Schrager's new hotel which is
being designed by the Koolhaas/ Herzog de Meuron team who are
hungrily eyeing the site. It is this convergent plan that provides
the basis for our student's study.
The problem has been organized into four parts. The first portion
of the studio is "Design In a Box", where the students
choose an art piece to re-interpret in the media of clay and cardboard.
The second portion of the studio entails an analysis and master-plan
phase where the basic structure of the site is defined. Thirdly,
an over-all site design is required in order to define the specifics
of the proposed environment. Lastly, a smaller portion of the
over-all site design is selected by the student for closer study
and refinement.
The course involves one field trip to New York City (not funded).
Detmold
Studio
GSD 1310-12, Fall 1999
Megan Mann MLA
'00, Model View |
The topic of the studio was the recharacterization
and design of an abandoned 50-hectare military site in Detmold,
Germany. The major emphasis was on the design of a landscape system
or infrastructure based on a concept that would create an image
and structure into which existing and proposed structures and
uses would fit. This landscape infrastructure had to include open-space
elements such as streets, pedestrian walkways, bike paths, parks,
green corridors, plazas, service areas, parking, and any other
landscape features (such as a munitions area) that comprise the
open space.
The problem posed to the students was part of
a real, ongoing project that government officials in Germany are
presently undertaking in order to find re-uses for such military
sites. This particular site is slated to become an extension of
the existing village of Detmold. It is essentially going to be
a "new town" into which the present town will grow, and is composed
of areas of mixed use, such as housing, commercial, work, and
institutions. The locations and nature of these areas are to be
set, although some buildings and uses have already been determined;
however, this initial redevelopment has begun without an overall
guiding concept for the visual qualities or image of the "new
town." The officials in charge wish to examine, at this point,
how the development of the landscape structure can help to organize
future development, bring a "sense of place," transform its present
image into an area in which people would like to live and work,
and induce potential developers to invest and develop. The guiding
belief of the government official (our client) is that the visual
enhancement of the physical environment through design and the
inclusion of art can help bring both an organization concept or
framework for the development of the site and interest, visibility,
and a new life to the site.
Marcel Wilson
MLA ’99, Master Plan |
Gold Mining in Geraldton, Ontario
Fall 1998
This studio considered future scenarios for a
disused gold mine and its relationship to the town's population
of 7,500. Fourteen million tons of tailings covering 190 acres
of landten feet deepcompose the principal challenge. In addition,
improvements to the town of Geraldton and its main approaches
were considered. The studio was pursued in conjunction with Mining
Engineering students from Queens University in Kingston, Ontario.
The studio was sponsored by Barrick Gold Corporation, Lac Minerals,
Inc., and John McDonough.
Design in a Box
GSD-1300, Spring 1997
With Rebecca Krinke
The studio immediately began with a two-day field
trip to New York City during which a work of art was selected,
analyzed and written about. This chosen artwork became the reference
point from which all design work in the studio was generated.
Problem #1, Box #1: Shoebox & Clay
Using the selected artwork, students were asked
to create a work of art integrating a shoebox and clay. This object
was to reinterpret (in the student's own language) his/her selected
work.
Problem #2: A Cemetery in Quincy
This problem asked each student to design a cemetery
to be located on top of a capped landfill in Quincy, MA. A new
typology of cemetery design was employed, characterized by a system
of concrete crypts that are stacked several deep inside a concrete
structure buried in earth. This concrete vault in the ground has
a resonance with the clay and shoebox problem described above,
but a cemetery is a place with a specific function and imbued
with powerful emotions. The shoebox and clay object served as
a source of inspiration for the cemetery design and both projects
was discussed together.
Problem #3: Boston's City Hall Plaza
Over 30 years ago, the Government Center Plan
which created City Hall Plaza was considered to be on the cutting
edge of urban design. Since its construction, the results of that
plan have been widely debated. The City of Boston recently organized
a competition to revitalize City Hall Plaza and Mayor Thomas Menino
has made its revitalization a mandate of his administration.
City Hall Plaza is the symbolic center of Boston
and serves as the civic gathering space for the city. Yet the
plaza has been almost uniformly criticized as being a lifeless
paved space: too big, too windy, too hot in the summer, and too
cold in the winter. This portion of the studio asks each student
to draw on all of their previous investigations into the development
of a personal aesthetic and bring that to bear on the redesign
of a major public open space: Boston's City Hall Plaza.
Art and Surface Mine Reclamation
GSD-1300, Spring 1996
The overall objective of this course was to explore
the landscape as an artistic medium. The student's formal solution
to the problem depended on the clarity of that student's personal
aesthetic agenda and his/her ability to express these ideas/sensibilities
through the manipulation of the land.
To demonstrate that selected mines can, through
the inclusion of design in the reclamation process, offer substantial
social, cultural and aesthetic amenities to the public at costs
equal to or below the standard costs of reclamation.
The means to achieve this objective were to redesign
a selected open pit mining site from those that have been geophysically
reclaimed in fulfillment of the Surface Mining Control and Reclamation
Act (SMCRA) of 1977, and regulations 30 CFR Part 700. The redesigned
landscapes offered, in addition to meeting required environmental
standards, "cultural landscapes" incorporating user amenities
whose economic, social, and aesthetic features can be benchmarked,
for value comparisons, against similar design features in comparable
locations.
The issue at hand was not whether reclamation
should be done, but how it was to be done. The standard requirements
for this process, although "ecologically" sound, are often accomplished
in visually substandard ways: mining companies may fulfill reclamation
regulations, yet the end results are often unsightly, awkward,
and underutilized. These "reclaimed landscapes" often remain isolated
from their adjacent landscapes and are visual eyesores. The continued
visual poverty of these landscapes also discourages reuse or reintegration
of the land for social uses.
The thesis of this course was that the goals
of the reclamation process should be broadened to include a visual
component so that despoiled landscapes can once again be useful
to society. In order to maximize the transformation of these sites,
they must be taken through a design process beyond that which
is required by the reclamation process.
The legal requirements and guidelines for the
reclamation process are quantitative in nature. They spell out
a specific number of trees per square foot, angle of slope, minimum
areas of ground cover, water treatment standards, etc. Because
of the difficulty in setting visual standards or a general lack
of expectation for reclaimed sites by the public, almost all reclamation
is done through engineering forms where there are relatively few
professionals who focus on visual or qualitative issues. The reclamation
process is focused on the quantitative issues of repair or the
technical aspects of rebalancing a natural ecology, but holds
no requirements that these repairs be done so that the result
is a visually attractive or sympathetic landscape.
The results of most reclamation efforts, whether
it be the capping of landfills or regrading and planting of abandoned
mines, is mundane and perfunctory. Most often, these sites remain
strange and awkward lumps, veneered with a thick skin of grass.
Transformed to a degree, they remain visual and cultural wastelands.
This course attempted to illustrate that when
a reclamation process includes a strong "design component," the
resulting product has additional value and potential for future
use, beyond that which results from our present set of standards.
We would like to make the case for the inclusion of new requirements
which include landscape architects and artists into the existing
reclamation process. This is the missing step in site reclamation
if that site is ever to function as part of our cultural landscape.
more student
work......
Design in a Box
GSD-1300, Fall 1994
This course focused on the importance of identifying
one's own personal aesthetic language for the purpose of exploring
a method for the generation of physical site design. We explored
the intersection between one's own personal aesthetic agenda and
the programmatic needs of a variety of urban sites.
The sites for this studio present a "BLANK PAGE"that
is, a site which is part of a man-made landscape and has no "natural"
attributes. These sites present the problem of creating a place
by solving man-made site conditions through our ability to envision,
imagine, synthesize, and dream.
The studio immediately began with a four-day
field trip to New York City during which a work of art was selected,
analyzed, and written about. This chosen art work became the reference
point from which all design work in this studio was generated.
While in New York, we visited our site for module 2, the World
Trade Center Plaza.
Quincy LandfillArt, Park, Parking
GSD-1300, Spring 1993
The entire semester focused on the 125-acre Quincy
Landfill through an analysis phase and a study of the technical
nature of this particular landfill. Students were asked to site
a program of possible uses on the landfill, such as a cemetery,
a park-and-ride MBTA stop, an arts park, and a homeless shelter.
The students were required to design these facilities to a high
level of resolution, taking into account the parameters of working
on a landfill site.
The Redesign of Jacob Javits Plaza, New
York City
GSD-1300, Fall 1992
The first part of this studio focused on the
issue of how one generates ideas and on the need to develop a
personal aesthetic language. Initially, we made a field trip to
New York in order to visit museums and galleries, and to conduct
a site visit for the design problem: the redesign of Jacob Javits
Plaza.
The initial task was to focus on an art work
that seems to address the stated problem, and then to express
the essence of this art work using a shoe box and lump of clay.
|